Review Criticizes Writing Style of Andrew Farley’s New Book

A recent review in Christianity Today evaluates Andrew Farley’s latest book, The Impossible Teachings of Jesus, which explores the Sermon on the Mount and the challenging commands found in Matthew 5. While the reviewer acknowledges that the book’s underlying theology appears to be orthodox, they argue that the author’s stylistic choices significantly hinder the reader's ability to engage with the material.

The critique focuses on a recurring literary device used throughout the 250-page text. The reviewer notes that Farley employs a specific conversational template—involving an anonymous questioner and a wise response—at least 23 times. The author contends that this repetitive structure feels formulaic and distracting, ultimately overshadowing the substance of the theological arguments presented. The review concludes that the book’s poor execution prevents it from effectively communicating its intended message regarding the teachings of Jesus.