Skip to content

United Methodist Judicial Council Upholds Closure of California Congregation

The United Methodist Church’s highest court, the Judicial Council, has ruled that the California-Pacific Conference acted in accordance with the denomination's Book of Discipline when it closed La Trinidad United Methodist Church in Los Angeles. The regional conference initiated the closure citing concerns regarding the congregation's financial management and declining attendance, which had reportedly dropped to 10 members.

In Decision Number 1526, the court affirmed that the conference followed the established procedures for closing a local church and transferring its membership. The ruling confirms that the conference properly exercised its authority under the Book of Discipline, which allows for the closure of a congregation through specific administrative steps involving district superintendents and the presiding bishop. Following the closure, the United Methodist work in the area has transitioned to a new ministry known as Nueva Esperanza.

While the court upheld the decision, five members issued a concurring opinion expressing reservations about the current closure process. These members argued that the relevant section of the Book of Discipline may contain an unlawful delegation of authority that bypasses the broader oversight of the annual conference.

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

Sources

Read also