South Dakota Supreme Court Reverses Ruling in Church Gift Dispute
The South Dakota Supreme Court has unanimously reversed a lower court’s summary judgment regarding a $300,000 financial dispute between Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida and a former pastor. The state’s high court ruled that Judge Patrick T. Smith erred by awarding the funds to the church without first conducting a trial to address fraud claims raised by the former pastor, Mario Torres.
The conflict originated in 2022 following a church-sponsored event in Columbus, Nebraska. Parish member Alex Cooper Vasquez, who had received a personal injury settlement, issued three $300,000 checks. While one check was made payable to the church, two others were left blank in the payee line with the word “mission” in the memo. Torres, who served as a pastor at a satellite campus, contends the money was intended as a personal gift, while the church leadership maintains the funds were intended for the ministry. The case has been remanded for further proceedings to resolve the underlying allegations.