Federal Judge Rules Maine School Board Cannot Deny Church Facility Lease
A federal judge has ruled that the Hermon School Department in Maine violated the First Amendment by denying a lease to The Pines Church. Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker determined that the school board acted with "bad motive" when it rejected the church's application for a one-year lease at a local high school. The court found that the board's decision was influenced by the church's conservative theological positions on issues such as abortion and same-sex marriage.
The legal dispute began after the school board questioned Pastor Matt Gioia regarding his congregation's social views during the application process. While the school board cited concerns regarding staffing, capacity, and logistics, Judge Walker concluded these were pretextual and that the board demonstrated hostility toward the church's religious viewpoint. The ruling affirms that if public school facilities are open to community groups, religious organizations cannot be excluded based on their faith or beliefs. The Pines Church, founded in 2021, had sought the space to accommodate its growing congregation.